RS best movies of year

Rolling stone's Peter Travers ranked 'em like this:

1.A history of violence
2.Brokeback mountain
3.Syriana
4.Good night, and good luck
5.Munich
6.Capote
7.The squid and the whale
8.The constant gardener
9.Crash
10.Wedding crashers
11.King Kong
12.Match Point
13.Walk the Line
14.The New world
15.The three burials of Melquiades Estrada
16.Sin City
17.Shopgirl
18.Cinderella man

best animated: corpse bride
best foreign: oldboy
best documentary: grizzly man, murderball (runner up)

I've seen Capote, Walk the Line, Sin City; all good. Let me know if Travers is a straight shooter